If I Were on Dancing With the Stars

I know what you’re thinking. All of America would be thinking it too. But don’t worry, it would be the first thing I’d say in my bio reel.

“I know I’m not a ‘star.’”

I would mean for it to come off light and airy. A way of immediately calling attention to the elephant in the room. But, seeing as I have no experience in front of a camera, I’d probably sound afraid or traumatized, as if I’d just walked out of 4 hours of detention where the teacher made me write 1000 copies of the exact same sentence.

I know I’m not a star

I know I’m not a star

I know I’m not a star

I’d probably try to smile at the end, but I’d look like my lips were at war with my teeth and I’d only recently discovered I have a tongue.

They’d have me walk you around my house, which is small and not full of awards or vintage popcorn machines or fashionable children, then they’d sit me outside in front of our one palm tree and tell me to talk candidly about my “normal” life.

“I’m a writer,” I’d say cheerfully, because that is true and I’d be proud of myself for forming words. But when they asked me what I write about I’d blank, and probably realize how long it’s been since I peed, or drank water, and I’d zone out thinking about dehydration and kidney stones. When I finally returned to them, I’d try to scan through the blogs I’ve posted, and probably settle on vague, one word descriptions that, while accurate, do little to insinuate the meaning behind the posts as a whole.

Ducks…and Cheetos…and weeds.”

The camera people would look at each other, communicating paragraphs of concern with each silent blink, then look back at me with a smile and a nod. They’d tell me I was doing great, even though we’d both know it was a lie.

When I met my partner, I’d probably end up hug-shaking them. You know, that “I’m going to give you a handshake. Oh? Are we hugging? It looks like you’re going in for a hug. Okay, we can hug. Wait, why is your hand extended now?” And then you end up shaking hands and hugging at the same time, sending a sea of teens into a gif making tidal wave.

On show night, as the intro reel played on, I’d be watching it from the stage. My body clad in glitter and fringe and my hair harder than the bodies of all of the professional dancers. I’d be looking at my partner with “oh shit” eyes as I realized all of America was watching me be a complete idiot, but he’d smile and rub a hand through his hair and tell me not to worry, that the first week is the hardest and just to have fun. I’d nod, escaping to the place in my head where the two of us elope and make the most attractive, talented babies, and then we’d hug as I tried not to hear the words play on repeat in my head.

I am not a star

I am not a star

I am not a star

As the weeks went on, I’d start to find my groove. I’d finish my routines, which would be a miracle because they’d all feel like marathons, and I’d do a lot of politely rehearsed, yet completely genuine nodding at the unbelievably beautiful judges that were trying their best to help me out.

Soon some of America would start to like me. They’d say I was “quirky” and “relatable” and “very brave,” while others would spend hours wondering why I was still in the competition, calling my dancing, “average” and “kind of strange” and “containing too many awkward facial expressions.”

One week midseason I’d become very aware of my boobs. I’d wonder if they’d always been there with the potential to look so nice or if the costume designer did some boob magic that morning. I’d probably make a corny joke like “abra-kaboobra,” using a makeup brush as a wand and then instantly regret it.

During the “most memorable year” week, where each contestant is required to sit in a recliner and make all of America sob, I’d have a spray tan disaster. The ladies at the salon would tell me they had a malfunction on the day I was supposed to go in and push me back to the day of sob story filming, making me freshly pumpkin when I arrived on the recliner. I’d then go into detail about 2014 and about how it changed my life and I’d cry/nervous sweat off patches of my tan, leaving me 50% pumpkin, 50% pale white girl and 100% Grey’s Anatomy mystery disease patient. My partner would say it was no big deal, that I could just get my tan redone, so we’d schedule another appointment for the only other time I had free: the morning of the show, which would prove to be disastrous.

That Monday night, Twitter would come alive with questions: “Is she dying?” “Did she try to tan in an oven?” “Y’all why does Kim look like a melted traffic cone?” It would be hard and I’d probably want to quit, but when I arrived at the studio the next day I’d find my partner a fresh shade of oompa loompa solidarity and I’d laugh and we’d shrug a “what can you do shrug” and then get back to dancing.

In the end, I’d go out in 5th place, just missing the finale, leaving many Americans wondering what the hell my “freestyle” would have looked like. I’d get emotional as I said goodbye to my partner and probably hugshake them while retelling the abra-kaboobra joke to try and stop myself from sobbing. Inevitably however, I’d straight up snot cry, thanking everyone for allowing an “average Joe” like me to crash the party, and I’d walk to center stage to slow dance with what could have been my baby daddy. As the lights dimmed and the crowd applauded, Tom Bergeron and Erin Andrews would tell me that they hoped after all this I could go home knowing that I am a star, that we all are in our own right, and that yes, my boobs look great.

Also check out: If I Were on The Bachelor, If I Were on Carpool Karaoke



  1. I can see you’ve thought a lot about this 😉 It reminds me of when I wanted to be on a spin-off version called “Dancing with The Average Joe”, which I would have clearly dominated.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s